Earlier this week, our (most of the time) good friends at MTV and Bunim-Murray announced that there will be (as if there was any doubt) a season 25 of The Challenge, America’s fifth major professional sport. Before we can rejoice in potential future happenings (Duel 3?), wants (Laurel to return, justice for Sarah), and predictions (Jordan is an early favorite to win) for the next season, we must reflect on the at times masterful and compelling, at times frustrating and degrading, but always reliable and entertaining just completed season of The Challenge: Rivals 2. Here is a thorough breakdown of superlatives and awards for the season that was:
Most successful use of little screen time: Anastasia, who was at the center of drama for her two episodes on the show that may have won her an improbable call to return
Least successful use of little screen time: Tyrie, whose one notable moment this season involved a very public bathroom experience
Person that hung around way too long for such a little contribution: Knight
Person whose stay in Thailand was way too short: Sarah
Most successful attempt to be silent: Ty
Worst attempt to be silent: Knight
People who had less screen time than Johnny’s Bobble Head: Tyrie, Dunbar, Robb, Naomi
Most welcome returns from at least a season of hiatus: Paula, Johnny, CT
Most unconventional workout: Aneesa, who ran on the deck through a burgeoning fight
A meltdown that I already forgot: Zach’s not so sportsmanlike exit
A meltdown that will be hard to forget: Camila’s out of nowhere (is there any other kind for her?) once a season blowout
The “It’s Time to Officially Retire” award: (tie) Trishelle and Tyrie
Low points of the season: Sarah’s unnecessary departure, Knight’s immaturity at the reunion
High points of the season: The “Bananas still has it” episode, Jordan’s hookup with Sarah, Diem’s courageous everything, CT and Johnny’s old vet conversation on the eve of the final
Most unexpected altercations: CT and Anastasia, Diem and Jemmye
Most expected altercations: Frank and CT, Frank and Jordan, Knight and Jemmye
The “My 2008 Self Could Never Have Seen This Coming” award: How well Wes and CT gelled, how Paula is in the conversation for all-time pantheon of Challenge competitors
The “My 2008 Self Saw This Coming” award: The Bananas and CT/Wes fight after Johnny’s challenge vomiting
The “Maybe The Outcome Will Be Different With Another Partner” award: Preston, who is so ready to distance himself from his New Orleans housemate
Best hidden camera moment: Jordan and Sarah’s closet hookup
Most competitive major award: Rookie of the Year, Jordan, Marlon, and Cooke all had incredible first campaigns (more on this in a bit)
The “Could You At Once Be On Time to the Party” award: Cara Maria, I just think it would give her better stability in those first few weeks
The “I Forgot You Were On This Season When Writing This Column” award: Dunbar
The Rivals 2 Media Guide Cover Would Feature: CT, Bananas, Paula, Emily, and Jordan
Best interview: Paula, consistently hysterical, self-effacing, and honest; Honorable Mention: Jemmye, CT, Jasmine
The “Sophomore Slump is a Real Thing” award: (tie) Zach and Nany
The “Sophomore Slump Doesn’t Exist” award: Frank
Best impression of a Marvel Super Hero: Jessica’s Princess Hulk
Worst impression of a Marvel Super Hero: Trishelle’s the Invisible Woman this season, Knight’s nondescript villain character that he always seems to play
Most in need of swimming lessons during the offseason: (tie) Marlon and Cara Maria
Best use of words: Johnny Bananas for the epic summation/credo “All’s fair in love, war, and challenges.” Honorable Mention: Aneesa for coining “Trashelle,” all of the #teamsubtitles communication between Camila and Jemmye
Worst use of words: Diem’s rap
The “I am Glad I can Rewind Because That Was Incredible” Award: Jordan, an uber-amazing athlete who kept finding more ways to show us why
Real World season that had the best showing: (tie) Key West (Paula and Johnny) and Portland (Jordan, Marlon, Jess, and Ana)
Worst impression of Kevin Costner: Knight’s fanboy bodyguard routine during CT’s early fights
Best impression of Kevin Costner: Frank ‘s incredible swimming was straight the Mariner from Waterworld
Best conflict resolution reflexes: Emily, at the reunion and when Camila’s drunkenness exploded
Best TJ Lavin moment: His delivery of the Zach elimination disqualification news
Worst TJ Lavin moment: When he told Sarah she had to go home. TJ, could you have at least tried to call an audible on production?
Vomiting that got the most play: (tie) Johnny’s in the final men elimination challenge before the final and the awful eating stage in the final
Best manipulation of “rivals” conceit: Johnny and Frank (A twitter war? Really?), Paula and Emily (they were thrilled to be together from the start and their performance showed this throughout)
Best player stock to buy (for future season success): Jordan
MOST IMPROVED PLAYER
MEN: FRANK
WOMEN: JEMMYE


Honorable Mention: Preston, Wes, Aneesa
Preseason Prediction – Men: Trey; Women: Jemmye
Midseason Award – Men: Frank; Women: Aneesa
In a very similar fashion to last season (speaking of fashion – Preston is setting trends – whether he has any followers or not is yet to be seen), Preston had a great last day, further showing himself as ready to be as far away from Knight’s shadow in future seasons as possible. Although some of his early season success may have been on the circumstantial end of the scale, he did make it within one elimination of the final. Wes, who had to go into an early elimination with Lacey last fall on Battle of the Seasons (an almost guaranteed subsequent loss), managed the social game as well as he ever has and has the hardware (or money in this case) to show for it. Frank is the ultimate winner of this award because, although he had some moments of his most volatile and uncontrollable self rearing its most ugly (but good for TV!) self, his leap as a loyal and dedicated teammate and friend was substantial. He and Johnny were an understandable hot (Thailand temperatures were an issue all season) mess (eating durian will cause this) during parts of the final, but Frank managed to keep any cruelty and low-blowing (poor Sam had to endure quite the barrage in Turkey and Namibia) out of the mix. His admirable passivity when faced with Knight’s premeditated violence at the live reunion is at the heart of what “most improved” is all about. On the women side, Jemmye narrowly beats out Aneesa for the award because not only did she have to compete in challenges and in the social game, but she had to learn to communicate with a partner who spoke an entirely different language.
ROOKIE OF THE YEAR
JORDAN

Honorable Mention: Marlon, Cooke
Preseason Prediction – Marlon
Midseason Award – Jordan
All three of them – Marlon, Cooke, and Jordan – had incredible rookie campaigns. Marlon was a fighter from the first night (I am still not sure why he and CT were fighting in the pool), successfully hooked up with both guys and girls and continues to walk the walk of being himself, and had the best attempt at bringing down the tomfoolery of Knight of anyone on the cast. His Challenge career has only yet begun. Cooke began in the no-woman’s land of a partnership with the endearing, but less than athletic Naomi (who had to go home for honorable familial reasons), but managed to take full advantage of her second partner’s improved competitorness. She fought through many an elimination, used her down time effectively (peeing or allowing others to pants her), and was a consummate cheerleader, motivator, and warrior in challenges. She too is primed for a successful future career, but her first season second place finish will always stand as a major achievement. Jordan ultimately wins the award (and was a legitimate MVP candidate) for not only dominating every challenge put before him, but for fully understanding his own strengths and weaknesses as a competitor both athletically and socially and then taking this information to adapt and evolve throughout the season as if he was the savviest of veterans. He found a perfect balance of being a rookie, respectful and aware that he would have to pay his dues to get to the finals, while also demonstrating a willingness to stand strong against attempts (poor Theresa felt so betrayed!) to persuade him against what was in his best interest. He was not afraid of the big guns (and at times told Bananas and CT thus), but he knew not to take too much effort to fight every battle (as the edit may have conveyed about him while in Portland). Jordan was in control of his game and dealt with each machination of adversity head on and without fear. Perhaps his greatest feat of the season: despite her brief stay in the Thailand house, Jordan managed to build a romantic rapport with Sarah that led to a little hot and heavy rendezvous in front of the hidden closet cameras. As he said at the time, “Physically Sarah is beautiful, and then add her personality in there and she is an amazing catch for anyone…Sarah is the kind of girl that you marry.” This now Rookie of the Year winner just gets it.
MVP
MEN: CT
WOMEN: PAULA & EMILY


Honorable Mention: Johnny Bananas, Jordan, Wes, Cooke
Preseason Prediction – Men: Johnny Bananas (runner up: Leroy); Women: Emily (runner up: Sarah)
Midseason Award – Men: Johnny Bananas (runner up: CT); Women: Emily and Paula (tie)
Johnny Bananas summarized the men side of this award best in the final episode: “You win some and you lose some, but I hate to say it, but I think that the team that deserved to win won today. Rivalry between me and CT aside, the guy’s put in his time. We’ve spilled the same blood in the same mud. It’s only appropriate for him to at some point get a win.” CT is the rightful MVP. As for the women, how can you choose between Paula and Emily? Only a co-win does justice to their season of dominance, teamwork, determination, drive, and commitment. They aligned from TJ’s initial partnership announcement and never strayed from their dedication and support of each other. They are so much of what is so good about this fifth professional sport.
FINAL RIVALS 2 POWER RANKINGS
MEN
- CT
-
Wes
-
Bananas
-
Frank
-
Jordan
-
Marlon
-
Leroy
-
Trey
-
Ty
-
Zach
-
Preston
-
Dunbar
-
Robb
-
Derek
-
Tyrie
-
Knight
WOMEN
- (tie) Paula/Emily
-
Cooke
-
Cara Maria
-
Sarah
-
Aneesa
-
Jemmye
-
Camila
-
Diem
-
Jonna
-
Nany
-
Jasmine
-
Jessica
-
Theresa
-
Anastasia
-
Trishelle
-
Naomi
One final note: It has been quite a ride this season for yours truly. Thank you for all of your feedback and the time and energy you gave to reading my usually longer than necessary pieces. Thank you to the cast for making this journey so enjoyable and for your consistent and humbling spreading of the word. See you all next season (and undoubtedly for some interim Challenge columns in between…)!